Research & Debate Society

Opinion Articles

Analysis, commentary, and argument on the political and social questions of our time — written by students engaging seriously with difficult issues.

Opinion
Are Pakistani Economists "Useless"? A Reconsideration

Dr. Ali Salman responds to Dr. Nadeem Ul Haque's sweeping claim that Pakistani economists are useless, tracing their historical contributions from Mahbub ul Haq's Human Development Index to modern social safety nets — and arguing that the profession's influence depends as much on political will as intellectual quality.

Dr. Ali Salman 19 February 2026
Read Article →
Opinion
Economics, Budgets and Fiscal Rituals

Dr. Ali Salman argues that Pakistan has turned the budget presentation into a national fanfare — and that this itself has become the problem. A case for making the budget a boring, stable, and honest exercise in public finance.

Dr. Ali Salman 7 June 2026
Read Article →
Opinion
A Climate of Performative Spectacles

Drawing on Herbert Marcuse's critique of one-dimensional society, this essay examines how social media has replaced authentic engagement with performative display — and what that means for political culture, mental health, and our collective search for meaning.

Abdullah Bin Khalid 11 December 2025
Read Article →
Opinion
Understanding the Dilemma of District Kurram: Extension of a New Social Contract Without Mainstreaming FATA

An on-the-ground account of the 2024 to 2025 Kurram conflict, tracing its roots from colonial-era land disputes and the Frontier Crimes Regulation to the broken promises of the 25th Constitutional Amendment.

Abdul Rehman 14 July 2025
Read Article →